Off The Shelf - The Plain Cake Appreciation Society by Tilly Pamment

Kath February 29, 2024

Bought At: Pre-ordered from Amazon, however I have since bought two copies as gifts directly from Tilly.

Recipes Made: So many!

I made A Plain Cake with Passionfruit Buttercream (p.16) knowing I had all the ingredients, even some passionfruit pulp in the freezer. It was a lovely plain cake, unfortunately especially so as my passionfruit were decidedly un-passionfruit-y! It was the least passionfruit-y passionfruit I’ve ever eaten, and I was quite disappointed to experience that when making this cake! I can certainly imagine however, how much better this cake would usually be with probably any other passionfruit than the ones I used!

I made the Weekday Lemon Cake (p.19) when I had some in season bergamots and can confirm it was delicious, as I’m sure it would be with lemon (or any other citrus). Another lovely simple yet very flavoursome and satisfying cake from this book.

Strawberry Streusel Cake (p.20) was the first recipe I made from The Plain Cake Appreciation Society, as it was a recipe featured in a Graziher magazine newsletter back in 2021. I liked it then as was happy to see it was in Tilly’s book. I have made it since with plums, then with donut peaches and raspberries. All versions were delicious, and it’s a great cake to make if you have run out of milk or have issues with lactose as this cake uses no milk, cream, sour cream or yoghurt. It is a great recipe to make if you want to use up some in season fruit, and the streusel topping adds a little something too.

I requested Pistachio and Rose Bundt Cake (p.30) for my birthday last year, and while we don’t have a Bundt tin as nice as the one Tilly used in her book, it was a delicious cake. Pistachio and rose are just about my two favourite flavours so I was definitely always going to love this cake. The only thing I would personally change if I made it again was to ice the cake once the cake had cooled, as the icing soaks into the cake after that and isn’t as spectacular the next day or so. Not a problem if you know the cake will be eaten on the first day however, but in our house these things do last a good few days.

The Raspberry Studded Tea Bars (p.36) are definitely our most made recipe from Tilly’s book. Between my Mum and I we’ve probably made these at least 10 times since September 2023. They are a simple cake, but are very tasty and very dietary requirement friendly as well - they are gluten free, lactose free and relatively low fodmap (depending on your almond and berry tolerance). We often have a batch of these in the freezer as they freeze well, and make the nicest snack when we don’t have time to bake. The first time my Mum made these she did include the ground up tea in them, however we’ve never added it since as we like them just as much without (and it makes them even easier to make). As you can see in the photo we bake them in a friand tin as we don’t have any bar tins suitable, and haven’t been able to find anything yet either. You still get 12 little cakes out of the mixture and they bake for the same amount of time as well.

I was lucky to make the Quince and Blackberry Crumble Cake using the recipe for Baked Quince (p.108) before quince were all out of season not too long after Tilly’s book was released last year. I love quince and knew this cake would be worth making. I made half the recipe of the baked quince (which is enough to make one cake, I did swap the orange for bergamot in the recipe as I can’t eat orange), and made the cake and it was just so so good. The brown butter crumble on top of this cake is a real standout, you can really taste the browned butter and it really elevates the cake flavour wise. I made this cake again with blueberries and raspberries once quince season was over, which I can also highly recommend. Similar to the Strawberry Streusel Cake (p.20), this cake can be made with many different fruits and served as a dessert or just a nice cake with tea.

I had some apples to use up later last year, so I made the Apple and Cinnamon Cake (p.113). From memory I didn’t have any Greek-style yoghurt as the recipe asked for, and used milk instead and it still worked really well. I didn’t lay out the sliced apples on top of the cake nearly as nicely and neatly as Tilly has, I ran out of patience when doing it 🤣. My cake may not look as good, but I can guarantee it was very delicious and very nice with a cup of tea.

Being a pistachio lover I had to make the Pistachio Cake with Rhubarb Buttercream (p.114). I also had some fresh rhubarb, however no cream cheese to make the Rhubarb Buttercream so I omitted the icing and put a few pieces of rhubarb on the top of the cake before I baked it. The cake is quite light so the rhubarb drifted all the way to the bottom of the cake, but it was no less enjoyable for it. This pistachio cake is quite different to the Pistachio and Rose Bundt Cake (p.30) texture wise, and I can see why a buttercream was Tilly’s choice for this one. I do really need to make this again properly, however if you have a craving for pistachio cake and don’t have all the buttercream ingredients, I would still recommend making this cake on its own.

Similar to the Strawberry Streusel Cake (P.20), the Matcha Tea Cake (p.117) was also featured in a newsletter from Graziher magazine a couple of years before The Plain Cake Appreciation Society was published, so I made it back then. I actually made it with freeze dried raspberry powder, a suggestion given by Tilly for those of use who don’t like matcha. It was a fun marble style cake, however I don’t recall the flavour being enough for me. I dare say matcha would be a much better substitute flavour wise if you like it.

Favourite Things About the Book: Everything! I honestly do love everything about this cookbook. From the photography and styling, to the design and colour palette used throughout, Tilly’s writing and the way the book is divided into sections/chapters, to the recipes themselves and the delightful use of flavour in each. The Plain Cake Appreciation Society is my favourite book of all 2023 releases, and remains so into 2024. I don’t think I’ve made so many things from one book in a long time (maybe ever?). When I open this cookbook I not only want to make almost every recipe, but I also just want to look at it all. Tilly’s photography is so captivating, it makes me wish I was as good at it as she is. The Plain Cake Appreciation Society has a really clear and cohesive vision behind it, everything just works and transports the reader or baker to a quiet moment filled with tea, cake and flowers. The cakes in the book are really anything but plain. The recipes are generally unfussy, and maybe I am taking plain to mean ‘boring/bland/tasteless’, when Tilly clearly means something more like everyday and comforting, but the flavours used in these recipes are not only exactly the things I want to eat, but in my mind are far from plain in the best possible way.

Bookmarked Recipes (to make later!): Berry Cloud Cake (p.55), Vanilla Cake with Baked Rhubarb (p.78), Burnt Butter and Blackberry Sheet Cake (p.94), Pistachio and Plum Cake (p.99), Malted Banana Cake (p.128), Ginger and Rose Madeleines (p.150), Date and Ginger Bundt Cake (p.156). and Citrus Madeleines (p.182).

Cookbooks Worth Waiting For in 2023 Part 2 - A Recap

Kath November 23, 2023

What a lovely stack of books!

The second half of this year has produced some great new cookbooks, and these were my picks for the best and those worth waiting for - surely I am not the only one who counts down the weeks to cookbook releases?!

Below are my thoughts on each book, they are all quite different but all worthy of their place on this list and on my shelf (maybe yours too?). My original thoughts on these books can be read here, plus you can catch up on past Cookbooks Worth Waiting For lists here as well.

Please let me know in the comments below if you have added any of these new releases to your cookbook collection, and what you thought of them!

The links provided are just for your reference. Links to books on Booktopia removed 15/07/2024.

The Plain Cake Appreciation Society by Tilly Pamment (July 2023) - I knew I would like this book. I was not prepared for how much I like it! The Plain Cake Appreciation Society is probably my favourite new release for the whole of 2023. This book is equal parts fantastic recipes and beautiful styling, photography and design. It feels like a warm hug, a comfort on busy or hard days, and gives a sense of Tilly’ warm gentle demeanour throughout.

The Plain Cake Appreciation Society follows on from a series Tilly started on Instagram where she shared a recipe a week, and called it The Plain Cake Appreciation Society. These cakes weren’t the three day project extravaganza type cakes, but more simple homely, yet very flavoursome cakes one wants to eat with a cup of tea most days of the week. These are the kinds of cakes I like to bake and eat, so this book has only increased the number of recipes I want to bake for that mid-week tea and cake moment.

Tea and flowers are taken very seriously in this book (as they should be), and each recipe comes with a suggestion for what tea to serve with the cake and what flowers might best accompany the cake. The combination of these elements, along with the gorgeous photography and styling, create a calm inspirational feeling that allows the reader (or baker) to know a nice cake (which despite the title of the book are really anything but plain - the flavours used will satisfy even the most complex of palettes), a moment of calm and a cup of tea are never far away.

I have tried a few recipes from the book, and I am planning an Off the Shelf post in the near future to go through all of them in more detail. So far the stand out has been the Quince and Blackberry Cake (p.108-10) which comes with the recipe for poached quince (I told you the recipes were full of flavour!). The cake has a brown butter crumble which is genuinely the best and most delicious crumble I have ever tasted. The brown butter flavour really comes through and the short amount of time taken to brown the butter really is worth it.

This is definitely a book for the bakers in your life (or yourself?!), I don’t recommend baking books all the time since I find so many of them are offering the same thing, or don’t feel like they have a really unique voice that really interests me beyond the baking books I already have. Tilly’s The Plain Cake Appreciation Society is the antithesis of this, and I am overjoyed to say it deserves a place on your bookshelf.

Portico: Cooking and Feasting in Rome’s Jewish Kitchen by Leah Koenig (September 2023) - This book really lives up to the ‘cookbooks worth waiting for’ element of this series! As wait I have! Sometimes cookbook titles from the US take a while to get here, and the release date for this book was changed so many times I had serious fears I would not get this book until early 2024. Thankfully Portico is now available in Australia (it can be around $60AUD so have a look around for the best price), and I can now relax knowing this wonderful book is at my fingertips at a moments notice.

As I mentioned a few months ago in the original post for this list, I did some recipe testing for this book back in 2021 and enjoyed all the recipes I made. I can now finally say that everything else in the book looks amazing too! As I thought, this book has a very different take on Roman cuisine and opens up so many more dishes to try from the Jewish community of Rome outside of what we might first think of when considering the food of Rome.

I really enjoyed reading Leah’s introduction to the book, where she explains her connection to Roman Jewish cuisine and the impact it had on her. The brief explanation of Roman Jew’s 2000 year history in Rome was also a fascinating read, and reading Leah’s writing on the Ghetto in Rome and seeing the photos taken by Kristin Teig, brings back great memories of my last trip to Rome many years ago. A friend and I made sure to visit the Ghetto and Via del Portico d’Ottavia and we ate fried artichoke and sampled matzah as our side to our meal (rather than some kind of bread). We took a tour of the Tempio Maggiore di Roma, and I now lament we didn’t know about the bakery that sells their famous Pizza Ebraica - a biscuit (not an actual pizza!) filled with dried fruit and nuts. Luckily Leah has a recipe for it on page 273.

Along with Pizza Ebraica I am very much looking forward to trying the Lemony Almond Cake (p.286), Stuffed Tomatoes with Rice (p.174-5) and the Whole Roasted Fish with Raisins and Pine Nuts (p.211). This is a book that is well worth adding to your shelf if you love Italian food and are keen to learn more and widen your understanding of more types of food from Italy.

Garlic, Olive Oil and Everything Else by Daen Lia (August 2023) - Daen’s first foray into cookbook writing is a fun look into her tasty cooking style, using lots of garlic and olive oil! These recipes are tasty and seem to be full of flavour. I really feel Daen’s cooking style translates beyond the world of TikTok and into our kitchens with recipes that are beyond trends, but are just good. I’d suggest Daen’s recipes maybe even suit this more traditional format better, as people picking up this book probably wouldn’t have an issue with the use of olive oil, salt or insert other random thing Daen has been criticised for on TikTok for - my only conclusion is those people aren’t really into food and don’t ‘get’ it?

Daen’s Spanish and Italian heritage really shine through in this book, and if like me you love the style of food and ingredients used in those cuisines, you’ll love this book. I hope we see more of this kind of format from Daen in the future, this book did feel like there could have been more (in terms of recipes, it’s quite a thin book despite it’s slightly larger size overall) and I’m hoping it’s just a first taste of what will we seen from Daen.

We have already tried the Pan-Fried Salmon with Cherry Tomato Confit (p.66), and I’m thinking I will need to make some of Daen’s Focaccia (p.96-99) and use the leftover Cherry Tomato Confit to top the foccacia! I really like the look of many of Daen’s seafood recipes, the One-Pan Roasted Fish Puttanesca (p.68) is high on my ‘to cook’ list, along with the Whole Roasted Snapper with Green Anchovy Butter (p.91). And I wouldn’t be getting the full Daen’s Kitchen experience if I didn’t make Confit Garlic (p.14)!

Gohan: Everyday Japanese Cooking by Emiko Davies (October 2023) - This book gives us a more personal glimpse into Emiko’s food history and influences in a way we haven’t before. I love Emiko’s Italian cookbooks, but this one is even more personal to Emiko as she has finally been able to share the Japanese side of her food self. We are so fortunate that she has, as this book feels deeply personal, and also really informative. I love the illustrated cover and those dotted throughout the book, and how Emiko has brought her trademark writing style to this book. In a similar style to Emiko’s previous cookbooks, this is a book you could just as easily curl up and read as cook from in your kitchen.

The recipes range from basics like how to cook rice, and make staples like panko breadcrumbs and pickled ginger, to breakfast dishes, whole meals and recipes that have been influenced by more Western cooking styles and ingredients that have become popular in Japan over the years.

These recipes are bound by the meaning behind the title of the book, Gohan. Gohan literally translates to ‘rice’ but as Emiko explains, when she spoke to her mother about naming the book this, her mother said that Gohan embodied the idea of an everyday home cooked meal, that wasn’t fussy yet was nourishing. “‘I think the best food is created when you cook for someone love’” said Emiko’s mum Sumie, and I think that, the connection to family via food (both past and present) and a connection to a place, really sums up not only this book but maybe a running theme of Emiko’s work more generally.

I am looking forward to making some Pickled Ginger (p.35), learning how to properly steam rice (p.80-81), try my hand at Japanese Milk Bread (p.221-2) and continue to read more of Emiko’s writing in this book and learn more about her, her family and Japanese food and ingredients generally.

Now and Then by Tessa Kiros (October 2023)* - If you have any of Tessa’s other cookbooks you will know her trademark style. The beautiful design, and use of pattern, the colourful ribbon bookmark and the recipes influenced by her life and family or travels.

Each chapter focuses on recipes influenced by a place or time in Tessa’s life (now or then). The recipes vary a lot, and in any other context might not make sense as a whole. But since this book is part cookbook part memoir for Tessa, it makes sense because it is her story. Many of Tessa’s books remind me of scrapbooks (albeit fancy scrapbooks!), and this one is no different. I can’t help but think Tessa must have a big say in the design process as this book has many personal touches, but also such a different style to many other cookbooks around.

The use of colour in the book is calm and inviting, as are the photographs throughout the book. Now & Then is a book you might buy for the beauty of it and the personal touches and story. Or for someone who is interested in peoples lives, the food that enriches them and beautiful things generally. I am looking forward to trying the Gingerbread (p.50) and the Pistachio Biscuits (p.381).

*This book was gifted to me by Murdoch Books, with the expectation a review would be written. All opinions are my own, and I would have purchased this book myself if it had not been gifted to me.

Cookbooks Worth Waiting For in 2023 - Part Two!

Kath June 15, 2023

We are almost halfway through the year, which means there are more new cookbook releases on the way for us!

There are so many cookbooks I am interested to see in the second half of this year. However the below titles are the ones I will buy or preorder without having a look through first as I am that sure I will like them.

As always this list a bit of a mixed bag, some come from cookbook writers whose previous works I have loved and others are first time cookbook authors whose transition from the internet world of cooking I am keen to see translated into our ever favourite recipe format, the cookbook.

Links are there for your reference (not sponsored or anything), and I suggest searching around for the best price as at the time of writing some of these titles are quite pricey (we can only hope it goes down closer to their release date?!).

To read my first Cookbooks Worth Waiting for List for this year click here, and to read the recap of that list click here.

Let me know in the comments below if you are looking forward to any of these books as well, or if there are others you have on your list.

The Plain Cake Appreciation Society by Tilly Pamment (July 2023) - The first book to be released from this list in early July is Tilly’s (of @tillystable) first foray into cookbook writing. I am really excited to see this one, as I’m sure many of you are as well. Tilly’s well known aesthetic is equal parts beautiful and delicious and to see it, along with her recipes, in a cookbook is something I am very excited about. Tilly has not just written this book, but styled and shot the whole thing as well - no mean feat! I was lucky to get some ‘insider’ knowledge about this book recently, and I have been told there aren’t too many recipes using chocolate (which I can’t eat), which brings me a great sense of relief (thank you Angela!). Sometimes I open a new baking book to find it so chocolate heavy I know I will barely make anything out of the book. But to know I am in safe hands with Tilly makes me all the more excited to see her book in a few short weeks.
Portico: Cooking and Feasting in Rome’s Jewish Kitchen by Leah Koenig (August 2023) - I have been looking forward to this book for what feels like a long time. Back in 2021 when the current pandemic kept us all at home, I was lucky to do some recipe testing for this book (along with lots of other people!). I made three dishes and loved all of them. I tried a fennel gratin, that had no cream in it, which I traditionally dislike in such dishes as I find them too rich. This gratin was so delicious I made it a couple more times. I also tested a chicken and celery dish that looked like it would be quite plain, but somehow definitely was not. The final recipe was a Roman Jewish version of arancini balls, which were delicious, if not slightly fiddly on top of making the risotto, but it was lockdown so I had time!
I cannot wait to finally see the other recipes in this book and read what Leah has researched and discovered about Rome’s Jewish kitchen. The food of Jewish Rome (and Italy generally) is quite different to traditional Roman or Italian cuisine, due to the religious rules known as kashrut (to prepare and eat kosher food) - no pork and no dairy with meat is the very basic ‘gentile’ way of describing it (there’s really more to it, you can read more here for a better description). Pork is so widely used in all Italian cuisine, that it’s removal changes the cuisine entirely in my opinion - so this book is sure to have very different recipes than other Roman/Italian cookbooks, and I am very much looking forward to it after enjoying many of Leah’s previous books.
Garlic, Olive Oil and Everything Else by Daen Lia (August 2023) - Another first time cookbook author, Daen has flown to the top of the TikTok food scene and is now sharing her recipes in a cookbook. I am personally not a massive fan of recipe based Reels or TikTok (I don’t even use TikTok honestly), however discovering more about Daen, her recipes and food in an ‘old school’ format (i.e. a cookbook!) is something I can get behind. I really like Daen’s use of flavours, notably those that come from her Spanish and Italian heritage - like garlic and olive oil! - and while some on social media may criticise their use, I think these ingredients and Daen’s recipes will feel right at home in our cookbook loving part of the world.
Gohan: Everyday Japanese Cooking by Emiko Davies (September 2023) - I think we all love Emiko, and her many books on Italian cuisine, however we are now finally seeing more of the food that Emiko grew up with and that is part of her food history rather than that of her current home in Italy. Emiko has spoken of how this book was a harder sell to publishers as they perceived a book on Japanese cuisine less ‘sellable’ than one on Italian, but I know I and many others are so glad this book is almost with us. I do not personally eat lot of Japanese food or ingredients generally, but I am keen to support this new book of Emiko’s as I know how much I love her previous ones. I know this book will be heartfelt, well researched and beautifully photographed as all her previous works are. And hopefully I will find some recipes that become unexpected favourites too.
Now and Then by Tessa Kiros (October 2023) - A few years ago I made it my mission to expand my collection of Tessa’s books. I found some older titles on eBay, and even one I’d never heard of in Books for Cooks in Melbourne. So when I saw we would finally be getting a new book from Tessa (her last was published in 2016 I think), I knew it would make my cookbooks worth waiting for list. What I really like about Tessa’s cookbooks is they all have their own very unique story and often bring the reader along in some kind of discovery of a place, cuisine or Tessa’s family/family history. No two books of Tessa’s are the same, however all are beautiful and always have really thoughtful design elements that bring such a personal touch to each publication. The description of this book says it will be part memoir, travel guide and food odyssey and it feels like it will be a reflective piece filled with new recipes and memories.

Links to books on Booktopia removed 15/07/2024.

Cosy Bakes for Cooler Weather

Kath June 28, 2021

Here in Sydney, we’re well into Winter now - and a COVID related lockdown - so here are a few cosy things to bake to enjoy the cooler weather, and take advantage of being at home.

. . .

I for one am quite relieved the cooler weather has really begun, I hate the heat, but also find it much more comfortable to cook and bake in the cooler weather. There are many Autumn and Winter inspired things I want to bake, and below is a little list of the recipes I have been enjoying or hope too soon.

This list is quite quince heavy, as to me, it isn’t Autumn without poaching a few quince!

On the long weekend I used this recipe to poach 2kg of quince, and am hoping to make the quince cake (pictured above) from my free eBook Seasonal Cakes and Bakes ASAP (get your free copy by signing up to my mailing list today!).
I saw the talented Tilly of @tillys_table post the recipe for this Blackberry and Almond Afternoon Tea Cake on Instagram a week or so ago, as part her Plain-Cake Appreciation Society (a society I would definitely like a membership with!). I immediately saved Tilly’s post, and hope to make it soon. I also think you could use poached quince instead of blackberries, which I may do since I have so many now!
On another quince related note, I made my annual double batch of Sophie Hansen’s Quince Chutney, which I am obsessed with and can’t ever seem to make enough of. The recipe is also in her book ‘A Basket by the Door’ and goes excellently with the pork sausage rolls on the page before hand (p.142).
Since there are still some lovely Australian plums in the shops at the moment, I made Leah Koenig’s Passover Cake which can be found in the Monday Morning Cooking Club’s book ‘Now for Something Sweet’. The recipe asks for pears and pecans, however I used plums and pistachios and it was delicious. And while I did use superfine matzo meal as the recipe says, you can substitute for plain flour and I am told it is an excellent cake made that way too.
For more cosy baking ideas check out my Cosy Winter Bakes eBook - I am going to be revisiting some of the recipes now the weather has cooled down!

Kulinary Adventures of Kath

Food Photography, Recipes & Baking